I’m at rookieball today, and my eldest son has a game. So - these kids are about 6-8 years old. Still little people (in my opinion) but finding their way …
It’s beginning to rain, but this is a make-up game for one that was cancelled earlier in the summer (rain, of course - seems like this is the summer of eternal rain on baseball nights) so they’re going to try to squeeze in as many innings as possible.
One little guy gets up to bat, swings his heart out, but doesn’t connect. As the only two spectator parents in the crowd for our team, I’m coincidentally sitting beside his mom. He’s out. No hit. And he’s devastated (he’s probably 7 years old). He comes off the diamond and you can see in his face that he’s so utterly disappointed. He’s heading towards his mom. His eyes well up with tears. I so feel for this little guy and just want to hug him. His mother says: “No - don’t start. You know what happens if you cry.”
So - I respond, instinctively, trying to break this energy by saying “that’s ok buddy - you can try again. It’s hard to hit in the rain”. He’s looking at his mom and getting more upset “but I just wanted to hit the ball. I just wanted to hit it.”.
His mom says ” that’s it - you know what happens when you cry. Get your stuff and get in the car.” And so it begins. This makes him more upset - likely because he is embarrassed, having super-intense emotions AND he doesn’t want to leave his team, his game.
She turns to me and very reasonably says: “he has to stop crying. So we’ve told him - if he crys, no matter where we are, we leave”. “Really?” I venture to say. “In our house, we are taking the opposite approach. One of my boys holds his feelings in so much, it makes his stomach and his head hurt. It’s good if they cry.”
I (of course) want to give this boy a big hug, build up his confidence in himself and send him out again … I can’t believe this is her parenting strategy.
She looks at me like I’m nuts, and leaves the diamond, her 7-year old little boy, crying and trailing behind her. And believe it or not, this is not the first time I’ve seen this happen. It happened about a month ago - with a 4-year old boy, on the TBall diamond. Four years old! He was crying and mom was threatening him with going home, if he didn’t stop.
So - here I have two thoughts. First: Why can’t boys cry? How old is too old to cry? When we teach our boys to hold in their emotions and not find a constructive outlet for them (which should be their parent’s arms and then a conversation to help them work through what they’re feeling) we are not giving them effective tools and strategies to carry them into their older years. Guess what? That bottled up, pushed down emotion will come out some day / some time. Likely in aggression and anger at themselves and/or at others around them.
Second: Is it about the child’s feelings or the parent’s? Are parents so uncomfortable with their own emotions, that they can’t handle the display of feelings in their own child? Or are they simply embarrassed? Well, in my experience - likely both are true. Is it hard to work through our own acquired emotional baggage so we can help our kids be healthier? Hell yes. It’s hard. But it’s the right thing to do. Otherwise we run the risk of recreating all the stuff we grew up with that was not as healthy as it could have been.
And is it embarrassing when our child is crying in public? Is it hard when they’re not doing what we’ve planned and what we want them to do at that particular time? Hell yes. But truly, how would you feel if you were having a bad day - completely devastated about something - brought you to tears - and then you go to the person you trust the most with those feelings (partner, parent, friend) and they embarrassed you further, and then marched you out to the car - all the while telling you not to cry.
Hmmm … not so good. I’m getting a tight feeling in my chest just thinking about it. Take 10 seconds. Put yourself in their shoes. What are they feeling? What do they need? Sometimes we don’t have to have the answers at all. Sometimes they just want a hug and to know that you love them. Even though they just struck-out in baseball.
Children need to cry. Boys especially need to cry. Give them a safe and warm place to do it. Once the crying is out, then help them sort through how they’re feeling. You’ll both feel better for it.